Three-dimensional genome landscape comprehensively reveals patterns of spatial gene regulation in papillary and anaplastic thyroid cancers: a study using representative cell lines for each cancer type

Background Spatial chromatin structure is intricately linked with somatic aberrations, and somatic mutations of various cancer-related genes, termed co-mutations (CoMuts), occur in certain patterns during cancer initiation and progression.

The functional mechanisms underlying these genetic events remain largely unclear in thyroid cancer (TC).

With discrepant differentiation, papillary thyroid cancer (PTC) and anaplastic thyroid cancer (ATC) differ greatly in characteristics and prognosis.

We aimed to reveal the spatial gene alterations and regulations between the two TC subtypes.

Methods We systematically investigated and compared the spatial co-mutations between ATC (8305C), PTC (BCPAP and TPC-1), and normal thyroid cells (Nthy-ori-3–1).

We constructed a framework integrating whole-genome sequencing (WGS), high-throughput chromosome conformation capture (Hi-C), and transcriptome sequencing, to systematically detect the associations between the somatic co-mutations of cancer-related genes, structural variations (SVs), copy number variations (CNVs), and high-order chromatin conformation.

Results Spatial co-mutation hotspots were enriched around topologically associating domains (TADs) in TC.

A common set of 227 boundaries were identified in both ATC and PTC, with significant overlaps between them.

The spatial proximities of the co-mutated gene pairs in the two TC types were significantly greater than in the gene-level and overall backgrounds, and ATC cells had higher TAD contact frequency with CoMuts > 10 compared with PTC cells.

Compared with normal thyroid cells, in ATC the number of the created novel three-dimensional chromatin structural domains increased by 10%, and the number of shifted TADs decreased by 7%.

We found five TAD blocks with CoMut genes/events specific to ATC with certain mutations in genes including MAST-NSUN4 , AM129B / TRUB2 , COL5A1 / PPP1R26 , PPP1R26 / GPSM1 / CCDC183 , and PRAC2 / DLX4 .

For the majority of ATC and PTC cells, the HOXA10 and HIF2α signals close to the transcription start sites of CoMut genes within TADs were significantly stronger than those at the background.

CNV breakpoints significantly overlapped with TAD boundaries in both TC subtypes.

ATCs had more CNV losses overlapping with TAD boundaries, and noncoding SVs involved in intrachromosomal SVs, amplified inversions, and tandem duplication differed between ATC and PTC.

TADs with short range were more abundant in ATC than PTC.

More switches of A/B compartment types existed in ATC cells compared with PTC.

Gene expression was significantly synchronized, and orchestrated by complex epigenetics and regulatory elements.

Conclusion Chromatin interactions and gene alterations and regulations are largely heterogeneous in TC.

CNVs and complex SVs may function in the TC genome by interplaying with TADs, and are largely different between ATC and PTC.

Complexity of TC genomes, which are highly organized by 3D genome-wide interactions mediating mutational and structural variations and gene activation, may have been largely underappreciated.

Our comprehensive analysis may provide key evidence and targets for more customized diagnosis and treatment of TC.