Does bilateral Wilms’ tumor involving the collecting system in children have a worse prognosis?

Background The literature on nephron-sparing surgery (NSS) in children with bilateral Wilms’ tumors (BWT) involving the collection system is mostly comprised of case reports.

The present study aimed to summarize the clinical characteristics, treatments, and prognosis of children with BWT involving the collecting system admitted to our pediatric surgery center compared with those whose tumors did not involve the collecting system.

A secondary aim was to discuss how to preserve more kidney parenchyma and prevent long-term renal failure under the premise of preventing tumor recurrence.

Methods Patients with BWT admitted to our pediatric surgery center between January 2008 and June 2022 were reviewed.

All included patients were grouped according to the relationship between the tumor and collecting system according to the intraoperative findings.

Group I included children with tumor infiltrating the collecting system, group II included children with tumor growing into the collecting system, and group III included children whose tumor did not involve the collecting system.

The clinical features, treatments and prognosis of the patients were analyzed.

Results Seventy patients were enrolled, including 20 patients with 25 sides of tumors infiltrating the collecting system in group I,10 patients with 13 sides of tumors growing into the collecting system in group II, and 40 patients in group III.

There was no significant difference in patients age and gender between group I and group II.

In total, 20 patients in group I and 9 patients in group II had partial response (PR) after neoadjuvant chemotherapy.

In group I, 22 of 25 sides of tumors underwent NSS; in group II, 11 of 13 sides of tumors underwent NSS.

During an average follow-up of 47 months, in group I, 6/20 patients relapsed and 2/20 patients died; in group II, 3/10 patients relapsed and 1/10 patient died.

There was no significant difference in 4-year overall survival (OS) rate among groups I, II and III (86.36% vs. 85.71%vs. 91.40%, P  = 0.902).

Conclusions To preserve renal parenchyma, NSS is feasible for children with BWT involving the collecting system.

There was no significant difference in postoperative long-term OS between patients with BWT involving the collecting system and not involving the collecting system.